10 Anime That Should Have Ended Sooner

0

Highlights

  • Shifting the focus to different characters and storylines can disappoint fans and dilute the original magic.
  • Changes in animation quality and writing can negatively impact the overall enjoyment of a series.
  • Repetitive plotlines, predictable conflicts, and lack of character development can make a long-running series lose its impact.

Every anime fan knows the bittersweet feeling of watching a beloved show overstay its welcome. You’ve grown attached to the characters, enthralled by the story. Yet, gradually, you realize the spark that hooked you early on has faded. Many anime started strong right out of the gate, even being hailed as instant classics after a first dazzling season. But lightning rarely strikes twice.

Related

10 Best Anime With Only One Season

Don’t have time to watch an anime with multiple seasons? Well, here are some of the best shows with only one season.

When viewers are left feeling as though they’ve missed something crucial or can’t follow the story’s logic, it’s a sign that perhaps the show should have quit while it was ahead, preserving the magic of the first season without diluting it with a less than stellar continuation. Sometimes, less is more when it comes to imbuing anime with memorability and mystique.


10 The Devil Is a Part-Timer!

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.74

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

The quirky reverse isekai anime The Devil is a Part-Timer! charmed fans with the unlikely bond between heroic Emilia and demon lord Satan. Their hilarious odd-couple chemistry and gradually deepening friendship made many hope for a romantic future. However, season 2 pivoted focus to Chiho’s unrequited love for Satan despite their lack of chemistry.

This change confused and disappointed fans who felt it diverged from the show’s original heart – Emilia and Satan’s growing connection. Additionally, season 2’s writing and animation quality dropped compared to season 1’s wit and vibrant visuals. Given the decade gap between the seasons, it may have been better if The Devil is a Part-Timer had left fans with the sweet memories of season 1.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Apr 4, 2013

2

Ongoing

CRUNCHYROLL

9 The Promised Neverland

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 8.5

The Promised Neverland

Release Date
January 11, 2019

Main Genre
Anime

Seasons
2

Studio
CloverWorks

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

The Promised Neverland began as a high-stakes, intellectual game of cat-and-mouse with strong horror and psychological thriller elements. As the story progressed, it shifted more towards a traditional shonen adventure with battles and confrontations. Some fans preferred the original tone and felt that the later arcs didn’t capitalize on the series’ unique strengths. One of the biggest criticisms of the second season was its significant departure from the manga’s storyline.

Key plot points and arcs were either rushed, altered, or completely omitted. In the anime’s second season, the Goldy Pond arc is completely skipped. Instead, the show moves quickly through time, glossing over many of the manga’s plot points, jumping ahead to where the children are already at the shelter, and then moving swiftly towards the series’ resolution. This change eliminates the introduction of key characters from the Goldy Pond arc and forgoes much of the development of Emma’s leadership and the children’s ability to strategize against the demons.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Jan 10, 2019

2

Finished

CRUNCHYROLL

8 The Misfit Of Demon King Academy

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.3

The Misfit of Demon King Academy

Release Date
July 4, 2020

Cast
Aleks Le

Rating
7.3/10

Seasons
2

Distributor
Netflix

Writers
Yūichirō Umehara

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

Just like a chef trying to recreate a signature dish without all the original ingredients, the second season of The Misfit of Demon King Academy found itself missing crucial components that made the first one so delectable. The departure from the simplicity and clarity of the initial episodes led to a concoction that didn’t quite taste right. The first season had a cohesive feel that was apparently lost in the next one.

Related

15 Best Manga Panels To Ever Exist

Mangas are known for their intricate panels and beautiful artwork. Here are some of the best panels of all time.

The series’ initial magic was rooted in its ability to balance the power fantasy with a lead character who had both strength and heart. When we ventured into the new season, it felt as if the storyline got entangled in its own complexity, turning the straightforward narrative into a labyrinthine plot that lacked a clear path through. Further, the change in voice actors in Season 2, due to unforeseen circumstances, disrupted the continuity of the character for many viewers.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Jul 4, 2020

2

Ongoing

CRUNCHYROLL

7 Fairy Tail

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.5

Fairy Tail

$35 $55 Save $20

Release Date
October 12, 2009

Main Genre
Anime

Seasons
9

Studio
A-1 Pictures Satelight, Clover Works

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

Fairy Tail is known for its formulaic arc structure, where the guild faces off against progressively stronger foes, often with the world at stake. While this can be exciting at first, the repetition of this pattern can lead to predictability and a sense of déjà vu, which might suggest that the series could have benefited from a more concise plotline. Early on, the characters of Fairy Tail show significant growth and development.

However, as the series progresses, there are fewer opportunities for characters to evolve in meaningful ways. Furthermore, throughout the series, characters often overcome seemingly insurmountable odds through the power of friendship and sheer willpower. While these moments are inspiring, they can also undermine the suspense of battles, as the outcome can feel predetermined by the narrative’s need for a happy ending. This can make the series’ conflicts feel less impactful over time.

Release Date

Episode Count

Status

Where To Watch

Oct 12, 2009

328

Finished

CRUNCHYROLL

6 Darker Than Black

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 8.0

Darker Than Black

Release Date
April 6, 2007

Cast
Christopher Sabat

Genres
Animation , Action , Drama

Seasons
1

Distributor
Bandcamp

Writers
Colleen Clinkenbeard , travis willingham

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • Shift in Tone and Style
  • Plot Clarity and Resolution
  • Expectations and Comparison

Darker Than Black burst onto the anime scene in 2007, dazzling fans with its dark, stylish tone and complex story of mythic Contractors with superpowers. The first season crafted a tense conspiratorial plot centered on the enigmatic Hei and his gang of fellow Contractors. However, the magic faded in subsequent seasons.

Rather than answering season 1’s mysteries in a satisfying way, later seasons only piled on more questions and convoluted world-building. The expanding story felt bloated next to season 1’s tight focus. Furthermore, the gritty, noir atmosphere of the first season gave way to a different vibe that some fans felt didn’t quite capture the essence of what made the original appealing.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Apr 6, 2007

2

Not Renewed For Season 3 Yet

Amazon Prime Video

5 Boruto: Naruto Next Generations

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 6

Boruto

$20 $30 Save $10

Release Date
April 5, 2017

Main Genre
Anime

Studio
Pierrot

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • Legacy Overshadowing
  • Comparisons with Naruto’s Journey
  • Boruto As A Protagonist Not So Popular

Some viewers see Boruto as a continuation just meant to capitalize on Naruto’s popularity rather than a creatively motivated story. Naruto enthralled viewers as an underdog ninja who grew into a heroic leader of the Hidden Leaf Village. After achieving his dream of becoming Hokage, it felt like a natural culmination of his epic coming-of-age saga. However, the spinoff series Boruto: Naruto Next Generations undermined that satisfying conclusion. This comparison can be a double-edged sword, as expectations are high, and comparisons are inevitable.

Related

15 Most Brutal And Violent Anime Recommendations

Only watch these anime shows if you can bear brutal killings.

Despite its pedigree, the reception to Boruto has been mixed, with some fans and critics feeling that it doesn’t live up to its predecessor. While Boruto introduces a new generation of characters, some fans feel that these characters lack the depth and development that made Naruto’s cast so compelling. Furthermore, Boruto comes across as spoiled by his prodigy abilities and status as the Hokage’s son. His arrogance and sense of entitlement rub people the wrong way.

Release Date

Episode Count

Status

Where To Watch

Apr 5, 2017

290+

Ongoing

CRUNCHYROLL

4 Seven Deadly Sins

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.6

The Seven Deadly Sins

$38 $70 Save $32

Release Date
October 5, 2014

Main Genre
Anime

Seasons
5

Studio
Deen

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • Repetitive Plot Points
  • Animation Quality
  • Escalation of Power Levels

Seven Deadly Sins has several seasons and a movie that covers the main storyline, with the series concluding with The Seven Deadly Sins: Dragon’s Judgement. The series has been well-received for its unique take on Arthurian legends, engaging characters, and exciting action sequences. There were significant criticisms regarding the drop in animation quality in later seasons, particularly the third (labeled as the fourth season on Netflix, Imperial Wrath of the Gods).

Fans argue that maintaining a higher quality standard might have been possible with a shorter anime adaptation. The power levels of characters escalated significantly throughout the series, which can sometimes lead to a disconnect for the audience. When characters become too powerful, it can be challenging to create tension and stakes that feel genuine.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Oct 5, 2014

4

Finished

NETFLIX

3 Tokyo Ghoul

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.8

Tokyo Ghoul

Release Date
July 3, 2014

Author
Sui Ishida

Artist
Sui Ishida

Genre
Animation , Action , Drama

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • Manga Fidelity
  • Pacing Issues
  • Follow-up seasons had more generic action shounen vibes

Tokyo Ghoul’s first season was a darkly gripping tale, as Ken Kaneki struggled to adapt after becoming half-ghoul. The internal clash between his human side and emerging ghoul instincts made for a mesmerizing descent into psychological horror. However, the story grew increasingly convoluted in future seasons. Too many new characters and factions cluttered the plot. Central themes got diluted as fights and action set pieces took priority over character development.

The anime adaptation condensed many character arcs and sometimes altered them, which led to a loss of character depth and motivation that was present in the manga. Some fans noted that the animation quality in later seasons seemed to decline, with less consistency in character designs and dynamic scenes.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Jul 4, 2014

4

Finished

CRUNCHYROLL

2 Rent A Girlfriend

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 7.0

Rent-A-Girlfriend

Release Date
July 11, 2020

Creator
Kazuomi Koga

Cast
Shun Horie

Genres
Animation , Comedy , Romance

Seasons
3

Writers
Reiji Miyajima

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • Stagnant Character Growth
  • Prolonged Misunderstandings
  • Dragging Out the Inevitable

When Rent-A-Girlfriend first premiered, rom-com fans were drawn in by the zany premise of a rental girlfriend service and the potential love triangle between Kazuya, Chizuru, and Mami. But as the seasons dragged on, the story became bogged down in repetitiveness. Kazuya obsessively rents Chizuru to keep up the facade of a fake relationship while denying his true feelings.

Chizuru insists she’s just doing her job, even as she clearly starts to care. Mami stirred up melodrama, trying to rekindle things with Kazuya through manipulation. The same story beats repeated ad nauseam without meaningful progress. Rather than moving the central duo’s relationship forward or adding refreshing new dynamics, the show fell into a rut of stagnancy. Still, fans kept watching, hoping to finally see Kazuya and Chizuru admit their obvious mutual affection.

Release Date

Season Count

Status

Where To Watch

Jul 11, 2020

3

Ongoing

NETFLIX

1 Death Note

My Anime List (MAL) Score – 8.6

Death Note

Release Date
October 21, 2007

Genres
Mystery , Thriller

Seasons
1

Studio
Madhouse

Why The Anime Should Have Ended Sooner?

  • New Antagonists Couldn’t Fill The Void After L’s Death
  • Predictability Increases
  • Ending Divided The Fans

Death Note is often praised for its concise storytelling, strong character development, and thought-provoking themes. The series concluded after 37 episodes, which is relatively short compared to many other anime. However, even within its brief run, there are fans who believe that Death Note could have ended earlier. A significant turning point in the series is the death of a major character, L (Light Yagami’s main adversary). Some fans argue that the series peaks at this moment, which occurs approximately halfway through.

The subsequent story arcs are sometimes seen as less compelling in comparison to the cat-and-mouse tension that defined early episodes. Following the aforementioned turning point, the dynamic between characters changes, and new characters are introduced to fill the void. Some viewers feel that these new characters do not carry the same weight or intellectual gravitas as the original cast, which impacts the series’ tension and engagement. Furthermore, opinions on the series’ ending are divided.

Release Date

Episode Count

Status

Where To Watch

Oct 4, 2006

37

Finished

FUNIMATION

NEXT: Death Note: Anime Characters Who Can Outsmart Light Yagami

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *